1869-1879 - Henry Meigs (5 Terms)

1879-1883 - Stephen K. Lane (2 Terms)

1883-1887 - David W. Oliver (2 Terms)

1887-1891 - John Newman (2 Terms)

1891-1895 - William C. Farr (2 Terms)

1895-1904 - Egbert Seymour (4 Terms)

1904-1906- Thomas Brady

1906-1910 - Pierre Garven

1910-1912 - John J. Cain

1912-1914 - Matthew T. Cronin

Jan. 1, 1914 - April 1915 - Dr. Bert Daly

1915-1919 - Pierre P. Garven

1919-1923 - W. Homer Axford

1923-1927 - Robert J. Talbot

1927-1931 - Bert J. Daly

1931-1939 - Lucius Donohue

1939-1943 - James J. Donovan

1943-1947 - Bert J. Daly

1947-1951 - Charles Heiser

1951-1955 - Edward F. Clark

1955-1959 - G. Thomas DiDomenico

1959-1962 - Alfred Brady

1962-1974 - Francis G. Fitzpatrick

1974-1990 - Dennis Collins

1990-1994 - Richard A. Rutkowski

1994-1998 - Leonard P. Kiczek

1998-____ - Joseph V. Doria